1.  1966-67    The Night of January 16th | Out of the Frying Pan | The Crucible   
2. 1967-68      The Solid Gold Cadillac | Pure as the Driven Snow | The Curious Savage
3.  1968-69     The Male Animal | The Haunting of Hill House | Bus Stop   
4. 1969-70       Mrs. McThing | The Tender Trap | You Can't Take It With You  
5. 1970-71        The Loud Red Patrick | Don't Drink the Water | Dirty Work at the Crossroads  
6. 1971-72         The Playroom | URBU | The Man in the Dog Suit   
7. 1972-73         The Impossible Years | Desk Set | The Royal Family   
8. 1973-74        Night Watch | MacBeth Did It | The Family Man   
9. 1974-75        George Washington Slept Here | The Savage Dilemma | Best of Friends
10. 1975-76         The Crucible | The Odd Couple | Lily | The Delon's Daughter 
11. 1976-77         Ring Around the Bathtub | Plaza Suite | Speaking of Murder 
12. 1977-78         Ducks and Lovers | Who Goes Bare? | Children! Children 
13. 1978-79         Never Too Late | The Night of January 16th | The Creature Creeps 
14. 1979-80        The Man Who Came to Dinner | Madness on Madrona Drive | Death Takes a Holiday 
15. 1980-81         Lilliom | The Butler Did It | Missing Link 
16. 1981-82         The Runner Stumbles | Play On | The Unvarnished Truth 
17. 1982-83         You Can't Take it With You | Harvey | June Groom 
18. 1983-84         Fools | My Three Angels | Whose Life is It Anyway 
19. 1984-85         The Male Animal | "Honestly Now!" | Shock! 
20. 1985-86         Barefoot in the Park | Hide and Seek | Don't Tell Mother | And Then I Wrote 
21. 1986-87         Alone Together | The Odd Couple (Female Version) | Ten Little Indians | Play It Again Sam 
22. 1987-88         This Must Be the Place | Monique |Light Up the Sky | Breakfast with Les and Bess 
23. 1988-89         Win With Wheeler | Squabbles | Love, Sex and the I.R.S. | DA 
24. 1989-90         Noises Off | Lunch Hour | The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 
25. 1990-91         The Curious Savage | An Act of the Imagination | The Murder Room
26. 1991-92          Said the Spider to the Fly | The Haunting of Hill House | The Bride of Brackenloch 
27. 1992-93          Rumors | Slaughterhouse | But Why Bump Off Barnaby? 
28. 1993-94          California Suite | Alice in Wonderland | Breath of Spring | Just For Tonight 
29. 1994-95          It Runs in the Family | The Lion, The Witch and the Wardrobe | The Silver Whistle | I Shot My Rich Aunt 
30. 1995-96          Steel Magnolias | The Best Christmas Pageant Ever | Beau Jest | Death of a Salesman 
31. 1996-97         The Foreigner | The Emperor's New Clothes | Social Security | Later Life 
32. 1997-98          Moon Over Buffalo | The Spell of Sleeping Beauty | Do Not Go Gentle | The Odd Couple (Female Version)
33. 1998-99          Pack of Lies | The Clown Prince of Wonderlust | Prisoner of Second Avenue | Exit the Body
34. 1999-00         The Nerd | Pied Piper of Hamlin | Little Old Ladies in Tennis Shoes | Romantic Comedy 
35. 2000-01        Done to Death | The Trial of Goldilocks | The Diviners | I Hate Hamlet
36. 2001-02         Rumors | Charlotte's Web | Sketching the Soul | Tribute 
37. 2002-03         Blithe Spirit | The Cemetery Club | The Elves and the Shoemaker | All I Really Needed to Know I Learned in Kindergarten
38. 2003-04         An Inspector Calls | Comedy Tonight | Charlie and the Chocolate Factory | The Curious Savage
39. 2004-05        Dracula | Don't Dress for Dinner | The Phantom Tollbooth | You Can't Take it With You
40. 2005-06         Deathtrap | Jake's Women | Winnie the Pooh | One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest 
41. 2006-07          Over the River and Through The Woods | Whose Life Is It Anyway? | James and the Giant Peach | Noises Off
42. 2007-08         Angel Street | Brighton Beach Memoirs | Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs | Leading Ladies
43. 2008-09         Hats! The Musical | Up the Down Staircase | Wizard of Oz | Harvey 
44. 2009-10          Sherlock's Last Case | A Nice Family Gathering | The Little Prince | The Philadelphia Story 
45. 2010-11            Dial M for Murder | Christmas Belles | The Glass Slipper | Enchanted April 
46. 2011-12            The Happiest Millionaire | David and Lisa | The Velveteen Rabbit | Jack and the Magic Beans | Lend Me A Tenor
47. 2012-13            The Mousetrap | The Velveteen Rabbit | Tom Sawyer | Do Black Patent Leather Shoes Really Reflect Up?
48. 2013-14            The Hollow | The Velveteen Rabbit | Alice in Wonderland | 37 Postcards
49. 2014-15            Becky's New Car | The Velveteen Rabbit | Sherlock Holmes and the Case of the Jersey Lily | Charlotte's Web
50. 2015-16            The Uninvited | The Velveteen Rabbit | The Ladies Man | Seussical Jr. the Musical
51. 2016-17            It's a Wonderful Life Radio Show | The Lion, the Witch & the Wardrobe | I Remember Mama
52. 2017-18            Postmortem | 1984  - Dramatic Stage Reading | Peter Pan and Wendy | Vanya and Sonia and Masha and Spike
53. 2018-19            Red Herring | Fairy Tales & Fables | A Night of One Acts - The Actor's Nightmare & Black Comedy
54. 2019-20            Lord Arthur Savile's Crime  | A Woman's Influence  | The Jungle Book 
55. 2020-21            An Evening of Mystery  |  Tidings and Traditions  | Words of Love  | Kirk Comedy Capers | Clue: the Stay-at-Home Version​
56. 2021-22            Night of January 16th   |  The Trials of Robin Hood   |  The Diary of Anne Frank
57. 2022-23            The Dining Room   |  Chasing Charming   |  Morning's at Seven
58. 2023-24            Murdered to Death   |  The Enchanted Bookshop   |  Arsenic & Old Lace